And I’m not at all sorry.
If you weren’t part of the now 8,500 strong group that has read last week’s story, click here to catch up on what you missed. It will take you to:
Some of the folks who read it, kindly called me:
“Disheartening and rude.”
“Snarky, mean-spirited, and quite arrogant.”
“Negative, pompous and absolute.”
Another commentator wrote:
“Seems like a severe case of sour grapes and he/she really needs to seek out a career change…”
People know me so well, don’t they? They haven’t got the faintest idea whether I’m a man or a woman, but they sure know my deepest motivations, and darkest desires.
Listen up people. There are psychics among us, and they know exactly what drives us!
If you’ve read all the comments, you know there were other opinions:
“A little reality check is always a good thing. And, as Paul pointed out at the end, if you’re a fool and passionate about it, then you’ll love every lonely, frustrating, fabulous minute of it!”
“As one of the doe-eyed hopefuls making these same mistakes and assumptions, I respect his perspective.”
“Knowing these truths and being aware of the harsh realities of the business is what helped me survive and get work.”
IT COULD BE WORSE
Should you belong to the group that believes I was impudent and impertinent, you must read a blog post entitled:
“Five Reasons You Won’t Make It As A Writer,” by John Hartness.
Here’s how it starts:
“I’ve decided to just embrace my role as the Simon Cowell of the writing world. I’m honestly tired of being nice and supportive to everyone who comes up to me with a half-baked idea or worse, a half-baked product, and asks what I think. Because they don’t want to know what I think. They want to hear how awesome they are. And most of the time they aren’t awesome. Most of the time I’d be better off trimming my toenails than reading their godawful attempts at a book or story, because at least that can get exciting if I trim a little too closely. So here goes – unexpurgated Hartness on why you’re not going to make it as a writer.”
And that’s only the beginning…
If, after reading that tirade you still believe I’m the rudest man in the voice-over universe, your skin is way too thin. That’s a serious problem, because -just as the life of a writer- the life of an average voice talent revolves around rejection. And if you’re not rejected enough, you’re not auditioning enough.
Now, is this me being negative and bitter again?
I’m not saying anything new. I’m merely stating a fact, and if you can’t handle that, you are being bitter. Not me.
RULES AND EXCEPTIONS
Here’s what most of my critics pointed out (and I paraphrase here):
While there is some truth to Paul’s five points, there are exceptions to his rules. Quite a few people are making a good living as a voice-over. Some are doing very useful work. It is possible to be social and productive as a VO.
To that I say: Big whoop!
I know a few actors who aren’t waiting tables in NYC or LA, but what does that prove?
Of course I’m generalizing. Anyone who has been in this industry for longer than a year recognizes that. But that doesn’t mean there’s no validity to my point of view. Here’s a quick recap:
– This world needs less talk, and more action.
– VO rates have been steadily eroding.
– Being a voice-over can be unhealthy, and lonely.
– Finding the work often takes more time than doing the work.
– It may take years before you make some serious money.
WHAT’S MY OBJECTIVE
Let’s be honest. Are these really the statements of some disenchanted, fearful soul, meant to scare newcomers off his lawn? Or am I simply restating a few arguments countless colleagues have made for many, many years?
If you have a problem with these conclusions, why shoot the messenger? Why not write to that online casting site you paid good money to, and ask them to raise the minimum rate, and to do some decent quality control? You’re an esteemed member. Shouldn’t you have a say in these matters?
And to commentator Scott Spaulding I’d like to say this:
You claim that there is money in voice-overs, and that’s fine. Your profile on Elance/Odesk tells me that your minimum hourly rate is $38. You voiced an animated infographic for $82! And you’re telling me that you’re “not working for beer money?”
Are you serious?
“(…) just because you work as a voice talent, doesn’t mean you don’t have any interaction with anyone. You can still pick up the phone and call a client directly to try to build a relationship that way. As well as cold-calling potential clients and try to build a report with someone other than through email.”
Yeah, let’s cold call a client to break the social isolation, and build a relationship. I’m sure that’ll go over really well. We all know how much people love to get a cold call. I haven’t had one in a while, and I really miss it.
I do have to commend you for your honesty, Scott. You said:
“I did find your comment about the voice conference speakers a little bit hypocritical though. You make a snarky remark about the VoiceVIP’s talking about themselves and plugging their own books at these conferences… when you’re doing the same thing on this blog! You have a link to your book on this page that says “Buy the book!” They’re using the conferences to help advertise and sell their book and you use this blog to help advertise and sell your book. You even plugged your book in one of your replies to someone who posted a comment.”
Are you saying that I shouldn’t promote my own work on my own website? What school of business did you go to? You’re on my turf, and the number one goal of this site is to generate an income. How is that hypocritical? You have samples of your work on your website, don’t you?
There’a big difference between landing on my site, and going to a VO conference. The 5,000+ people who visit my site every month pay zero dollars. What do they get for that? Over 120 blog posts that many visitors find informative, entertaining, and thought-provoking. Unlike some VO-conferences, I’m not asking people to pay a hefty fee for my privilege to plug my products.
Scott, I totally disagree with you on your definition of “productive.” You said:
“Whatever you’re doing that is helping build your VO business IS being productive. Whether it’s looking up places to contact, working on a new demo, emailing potential clients, looking up new marketing ideas… it’s all part of working towards your goal of getting business!”
Being busy does not equal being productive.
In any business, input leads to output. Input can be anything used to produce a product or a service (such as writing newsletters and emails, producing demos, making calls). Productivity is measured by the result of those actions. It’s the output that matters.
When you’re delivering services at a more rapid rate than before, you’re being more productive. Not when you’re making more calls, or when you’re doing market research.
As an envelope-pushing, pot-stirring blogger I accept the fact that people will criticize and ridicule me. Different opinions and dialogue are welcome, as long as we can have a civilized discussion.
I also realize that not everyone gets my tongue-in-cheek style. People tend to take the written word more literally, and snarcasm is not for everyone.
I never ask my readers to agree with anything I’m suggesting, but here’s the thing. I don’t provoke for the sake of provocation. The aim of last week’s piece was to provide a counterweight to all the propaganda from companies that are still trying to sell the same old story to a new, naive audience. If anything, I had expected a firm response from those companies. Instead, some colleagues accused me of dissuading newbies to join my club.
“If you don’t have anything positive to say, then perhaps you shouldn’t say it,” is their advice.
Sorry, but that’s not how I was raised.
If you’re a regular reader of my blog, you know I do more than complain and campaign. And when I spot things in my industry that seem unfair or downright wrong, I speak up. I don’t care if that makes a few people uncomfortable. As long as things are comfortable, nothing will change.
So, allow me to be that self-appointed watchdog. I may step on a few toes here and there, but my bark is worse than my bite.
You see… I told you so:
This industry is going to the dogs!
Paul Strikwerda ©nethervoice
PS Be sweet. Please retweet.